Here is our opinions of the trades that happen in the last week winter meetings. Sorry for the delay!
1. Twins and Ray
TWINS GET : Delmon Young, Brendan Harris, Jason Pridie
RAY GET : Matt Garza, Jason Bartlett, Eduardo Morlan
Winner
This trade is so close to a wash as it gets, both teams lose players from their systems that they have had prior bad blood with, Delmon Young threw a bat at an umpire and was suspended two seasons ago, along with a fall out with manager Joe Madden at the end of last season. Matt Garza at the end of spring training called out the Twin's organization and told the media how disappointed and robbed that he felt for not making the opening day roster. But both are the headliners of the trade. I think that if I had to pick a winner it is the Twin's, they are getting the more proven player in Young, and if he finds a way to walk a little more he could be a top 25 hitter in baseball in the near future. And they get a guy in Pridie (AAA prospect) that will compete for the starting gig in center next year. Where Garza on the other hand is unproven in the bigs, but will fit nicely as the number three after Kazmir and Shields next season.
2. White Sox and D-Backs
WHITE SOX GET:
OF Carlos Quentin
D-BACKS GET:
1B Chris Carter
Winner
Still up in the air because who knows how good this Carter guy is going to be. Has been reported by Baseball America as has good pop to all fields, but would see the field in Arizona anytime soon. Just a AA prospect last season. And the White Sox acquirer a guy that will compete for a starting role in left next season. I can’t pick a winner, but I can certainly pick a loser if that makes any sense at all. The D-Backs main goal of the off-season is to make a deal for a pitcher, and they still haven’t done that. Now Carlos Quentin has a lot of upside and has proven that he can hit in AAA, which would draw some interest from teams that would be willing to give them that lower tier hurler the D-Backs most desperately need. We just don’t understand the point of trading him for someone that wouldn’t help you right now, or at least holding the deal off a couple of weeks until you make the move. They are reportedly in on Dan Haren from the Athletics, and Quentin isn’t talented enough to make the deal by himself, but could have been a nice late throw in if talks with Billy Bean started to go south, and now he is unavailable. To reiterate, the D-Backs drop the ball on this one.
3. Nats And D-Ray
NATIONALS GET:
OF Elijah Dukes
RAYS GET:
LHP Glenn Gibson
Winner
When this deal first broke the Rays gave the Nats, Dukes for a player to be named later, which makes you assume that they are just giving him up for any Tom, Dick, or Harry in the the Nationals system. Which is why I was surprised to see that the Nats had to give up Gibson. Gibson was the same player that Bowden balked at a few months prior when the Rays first discussed the trade and that is why it didn’t go down during the season. He is a young left handed pitcher that averaged a K per inning last season. It is rare to see both teams get exactly what they want from a trade, but it looks like everyone is happy here. Both Win in this case.
4. Cubs and Braves
BRAVES GET:
LHP Will Ohman
IF Omar Infante
CUBS GET:
RHP Jose Ascanio
Winners
I really like this trade for the Cubs, They get rid of two player that will earn about 4 million dollars together next year, and neither are important to the team. The Cubs have enough lefties in the pen and more utility infielders riding the bench. And in return they get a hard throwing right hander that has a good slider, and could make a run at the pen rotation next season if the Cubs use any of those other arms to make a big move. I think he will end up throwing for the AAA club to start the season, but could become a major factor in a year or two.
5. The big one
TIGERS GET:
3B Miguel Cabrera
LHP Dontrelle Willis
MARLINS GET:
OF Cameron Maybin
LHP Andrew Miller
C Mike Rabelo
RHP Eulogio De La Cruz
RHP Burke Badenhop
RHP Dallas Trahern
Winners
Short run: Obviously the Tigers, they get one of the best hitters in baseball along filling out a top three of a rotation that could be considered the best in baseball along with right handers Verlander and Bonderman. Long Run: I think the only way that the Tigers aren’t kicking themselves if they win the World Series. Cameron Maybin is going to be a star in this league, I just hope that the Marlins do the right thing and put him in the minors for a little but longer, he is just 20 years old, and still has a lot to learn about the game. Andrew Miller and Dontrelle could be a wash this season, I really think that Miller with they right pitching coach, to help with some mechanical issues could see better success in every category then Dontrelle next year except wins, for obvious reasons.
6. Nats and Yankees
NATIONALS GET:
RP Jonathan Albaladejo
YANKEES GET:
SP Tyler Clippard
I like this move for the Nats, they get a guy that can compete with their other young kids for a spot in the rotation. In the one start I saw of Clippard’s, I saw some really good things. And lets face it, the Nat’s need pitching. On the other hand the Yankee’s get hard throwing right-hander that will step right in as a middle reliever. I still like the move for the Nats, just because of there major need.
7. The trade of never will be's
TIGERS GET:
OF Freddy Guzman
RANGERS GET:
1B Chris Shelton
Freddy Guzman was out of options, and Shelton has been the most expendable player in the majors after April 30th 2006. Where the first basemen put up career numbers in the month, and really hasn’t hit well sense. I think it is a good move for Texas to get Shelton just because they have nobody else to play first, but he will not make an impact on this team unless luck strikes twice.
Signing
1. Andruw Jones to the Dodgers
This was a great move by Colletti, he gets the middle of the order pop that he needed and didn’t have to give up the farm, or break the bank over a long period of time. Andruw gets a very large signing bonus, 12 million, but it is a low risk considering if they were to sign him after last season they would be paying more than the Blue Jays are paying Wells and for 5 years also. And as a side note this gives the Dodgers a chance to move Pierre to left so the defense gets better. Or move him to any sucker that will take that contract, can you say Rangers.
That was really the only big signing that happened last week. It was a good week of rumors galore, and if you are interested in good rumors year round check out the MLB trade rumors link on the right side of the page.
Scott